Showing posts with label DBR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DBR. Show all posts

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Using CCPM instead of DBR for manufacturing

The Proceedings of ICM 2007 is a 626 pages long document that has 2 TOC related articles. I'll review "A Feasible Case Study of Applying Critical Chain Multi-Project Management in Semiconductor Turnkey Services" which you can find in page 64 (using the reader's page count), the other article is about distribution and I reviewed it in a previous post.
This article reports the findings of theoretical simulation work done to assess the use of CCPM as a production management tool for foundries that serve fab-less semiconductor companies. While the researchers claim CCPM resulted in superior on time deliveries and a better throughput (probably meaning better output speed/volume, not the TOC meaning of throughput), they conclude it is only partially fits turn key projects. Since the methods used in this research are not completely conveyed and the understanding of CCPM in a multi project environment is not proved, this conclusion should be taken with a grain of salt.
I think the major take away is the innovative approach embedded in using CCPM as a production management tool, instead of a DBR variation, to try and handle the highly complex environment of the fab.

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Using S-DBR for Rapid Response Manufacturing

In this 2006 article,
 Eli Schragenheim, explains how to use S-DBS to support a competitive advantage of accepting requests for faster delivery dates in return for a premium.
S-DBR is short for simplified DBR and Schragenheim claims it has now totally replaced DBR in the GG consulting work. This is due to the fact that the classic DBR has too much protection in it and was overly rigid - the schedule was set at such a level of detail that each time a change was needed it impacted the entire system. This means that local variance is amplified to the entire system. S-DBR, on the other hand, uses only one layer of protection, meant to protect the system as a whole and leaves the micro-management to the people who can do it the best - the floor operators and foremen. The explanation of S-DBR and its mechanism is very detailed and clear.
While S-DBR can be used in any manufacturing system (made to order, to stock, to availability and so on) the focus of this article is made to order. In this kind of environment there may be customers willing to pay more for expedited treatment. Adding the ability to respond rapidly without negatively impacting the standard operations can allow the company to gain those premiums, establishing a decisive competitive edge. The article shows how to reserve capacity for the expedited orders and how to manage them.